Where the Wind Whispers to the Way (BJRE108)
Where the Wind Whispers to the Way
How Jesus Youth holds charism and structure together
(Prepared by Dr. Edward Edezhath for Kairos Global Magazine in 2026)
Our Tuesday committed group meetings were always lively, and their beginnings were special, too. It began out of a felt need in the Wednesday prayer group; as it grew, the leaders sensed we needed something more.
In those days, we kept getting a recurring message in the group: God wants us to be His presence in the world. The core group reflected, prayed, and then took a step. We invited anyone who wanted to meet regularly to share, grow together, and ask where the Lord was leading. That was how it began. About eighteen to twenty young people began meeting regularly on Tuesdays.
The tension between enthusiasm and order was obvious. Many shared their inspirations, their dreams, and what they sensed the Lord was saying. The meetings were spontaneous and exciting, but spontaneity is not the same as consistency. Some said we talked about many things and acted on few. A handful were good at taking those ideas and turning them into clear, practical steps.From this, several initiatives took shape: a Saturday intercession group, outreach into the slums, work with young people in parishes, and more. After much thought and discussion, we also began “Life in the Spirit” seminars. Two streams had emerged. One carried enthusiasm, inspiration, fun, and joy. The other carried planning, structure, and activity.
Looking back, as the group became more orderly and ministries became more visible, many complained that the early vibrancy and joy were fading. Some felt the Spirit's movement had become less perceptible, replaced by dry planning and busyness. The tension was real: unpredictable enthusiasm, joy, and freedom on one side, and the need for plans, teams, and structure on the other. The challenge was to have the best of both, holding the wind of the Spirit together with the pathways that move us forward.
Who will win: the wind or the way?
You may know the story of the two wolves. A grandfather tells his grandson that two wolves are fighting inside him, one evil and one good. “Which one will win?” the boy asks. “The one you feed,” the grandfather says.
In a group, we might ask the same question: which will win, charism or structure? The trouble is that most leaders tend to be people of order. So, little by little, groups become well-structured and disciplined; the dreamers and the “confusers” quietly disappear.
But the Kingdom's journey is not a competition. It is one where everyone wins, and the Lord’s plan grows. Neither the wind nor the way should gain the upper hand. They need to work hand in glove.
I sit and listen to many Jesus Youth groups. On one side, a few people share a personal restlessness, a sense that something needs to happen. Many feel unaccepted, discouraged, or lost. On the other side, some speak up for discipline, planning, systems, and sensible ways of doing things. The result is a clash between a vague feeling that something is missing and a clear argument for predictable structures. Usually the reasonable, systematic side wins, and the undefined inspirations get steamrolled. There has to be another way. The task is not for one side to dominate, but to balance the unseen push of the wind with clear pathways forward.
Balancing inspiration and planning
In the early days of building youth ministry in Kerala, Fr. Augustine Thuruthimattam contrasted the visionary, plan-focused leaders of the central region with the charism- and inspiration-minded leaders of the north, and stressed the importance of bringing the two together.
Fortunately, we had many opportunities to gather, listen to one another, and work together. A handful of seniors, including Fr. Augustine, Fr. Abraham, Sr. Cleopatra, James Abraham, V. T. George, and Alicekutty, had a gift for walking alongside different people, lending them confidence and clarity, and sitting together to see beyond conflict.
Later, leaders began gathering in what we called the First-line group. There, people with very different charisms and outlooks got ample time and space to come together, thrash out issues, speak openly, listen deeply, pray, and gently discern the way ahead. Despite the distances and busy schedules, we met one weekend every month, not for training, but simply to be together. The space to talk, the readiness to really look at one another, and the effort to connect and understand everyone created a vision of inclusiveness. Together, we watched what the Spirit was doing and pursued the distant dream of the Kingdom, balancing the wind's unclear murmuring with the path's clarity.
How to balance the wind and the way
A few years ago, when Pope Francis began emphasizing synodality across the Church, I could not grasp the word's significance. Then I heard about an academic course on synodality offered by a US university, and I readily joined. It helped me see why journeying together as a community matters so much, not only for the Church as a whole but for growing as leaders, building community, and launching mission.
Looking back on the Jesus Youth journey, I realized that the desire to discern together, by sitting, listening, talking, and praying, has always been there. In earlier days, we called it dreaming together, community dialogue, or group discernment. Today it is gathered under one word: synodality. It has been the spirit of Jesus Youth, and the secret of how the movement grew and spread.
What does this synodal approach look like in practice?
It begins with a shared conviction. The Spirit is at work building God’s Kingdom, and we are varied instruments gathered together. Whether in leadership or as ordinary members, everyone has a part to play.
It values every person. Because the Spirit moves each of us differently, listening and attentiveness become essential.
It makes time. Unhurried time together, attentive to one another, is the foundation for moving forward as a community, finding our mission and bearing fruit.
It needs a few mindful, visionary leaders. At least a handful in each community are needed to nurture this way of working.
It stays open to surprise. We must go beyond techniques, whether prayer methods or managerial and psychological tools, and remain open to the Spirit's unexpected movements and to what emerges from the group.
Our committed group meetings, and later the First-line gatherings, are worth revisiting today. We tried to listen closely to hesitant voices of disappointment, small inspirations and suggestions, and, above all, to every person, whether eager to share or slow to speak. There were also the systems people, who wanted clearer plans, better teamwork, and measurable outcomes. The best part was the intentional dialogue and honest disagreement, with plenty of smiles. No one won the race. Instead, the Lord’s work moved forward, and countless young people and families had the chance to encounter His love.

Comments
Post a Comment